Pluses and minuses of public shaming

Public Shaming

Argumentative Essay

What if you knew that if you drove drunk you would have to wear a sign about your neck saying that you did? In case you assaulted someone, how would you feel should you had to publicly apologize? Might you be quick to commit against the law? This is what The state of texas judge, Allen Poe, truly does in his state. I believe that public shaming is effective, but only in certain cases.

What is open public shaming? Every time a person continues to be convicted of any crime, they have the choice of both going to imprisonment, or being publicly humiliated. An example of one of many methods that Poe has used was when a man got beaten his wife. Poe was discouraged to see that the wife was horribly embarrassed but which the man was not. Poe sentenced this person to do incarceration and widely apologize to his partner. Poe afterwards commented, “He was humiliated, and this individual didn’t like it at all. ” Another example of public shaming have been thieves who have been built to wear an indicator outside the store they have robbed stating that they robbed the store.

What are the merits to community shaming? Well, Judge Poe states regarding the fifty nine shaming phrases he features given, simply two of all those criminals include ended up in jail once again. A store owner commented that since Poe had sentenced the robber to stand outside of his store, thefts had gone down. Mothers had been bringing their children to look at him as an example of what happens if that they committed criminal offenses. Also, in the event public shaming is used, it could even lower taxes. In the event that people aren’t going to imprisonment, if people aren’t coming back time after time, we don’t have to pay money for jails and prisons to keep them.

However , the moment there are upsides, there are also disadvantages. In some cases, the shaming may be more dangerous than useful to rehabilitation, in the event taken past an acceptable limit. In Illinois, a sign was put up in the lawn of your battery arrest that said “Warning! A violent felon lives here! Get into at your own risk! inch I believe that the is taking it past an acceptable limit. It almost seems as if he is generically mass marketed to the public as a huge, not a man who made mistakes. Another reason why open public shaming could be bad is basically because it can spark violence in anyone. The thought process is usually, “If the federal government can do it, thus can I, ” or “If the government has been doing ti, it should be right. inch One community sent out fliers to everybody about a sexual intercourse offender telling them of his whereabouts. Within several hours the offender’s house was set on open fire, his grandmother’s house was egged, fantastic other family members received death threats. This can be wrong, wrong, wrong! This begs problem: Would this kind of have took place without the fliers? Would people have done this on any other normal time?

Several say that open public shaming makes sure that the culprit feels accountable and will not do it again. Others say that open public shaming must be compared to what the Mao as well as the Nazis would. When community shaming is used in moderation, it can be very effective.