Compare and contrast essay Essay

Brownish Brothers; Just how Negative Stereotypes Affect Hawaiian And Maori In New Zealand ‘My demographic is: high school washing ladies, junk food burger-making, manufacturing plant boxpacking, rubbish truck drivers, bus drivers, taxi drivers, sober individuals and living off the pension check joy bikers — We am a dropout. ‘ These are every ideas elevated and challenged by Joshua Iosefo’s 2011 viral conversation, ‘Brown Brother’. ‘Brown Brother’ is certainly one of three text messaging that will be analyzed, compared and contrasted through this essay.

The other text, ‘Manurewa’, is a video clip based on the South Auckland murder of Navtej Singh, a liquor shop owner. The third text message is ‘Fish Heads’, a quick story authored by Aparina Taylor, that focuses on a group of Maori boys who have live in the location. The mass media is a huge primary cause for the negative stereotyping that has been brought upon pacifica people. Brown people are more than what they are described to be through media. Motion pictures such as ‘Manurewa’ reinforce most of the negative stereotypes that have been brought upon Pacific people.

The stereotype of ‘brown’ people is a bad one, one among unemployment, certainly one of crime, certainly one of violence. In ‘Manurewa’ each one of these stereotypes had been portrayed. The men in the video clip were almost all unemployed, every committed criminal offense and all demonstrated violence. “Bro Town, Sione’s Wedding, and do I have to refer to the GC? Now I don’t mean to condescend – I mean these kinds of shows great, don’t misunderstand me – although can anyone explain: will there ever become a time once our portrayal goes more deeply than placing our own visitors to shame? ” Joshua Iosefo, in his ‘Brown Brother’ speech, spoke regarding this issue – how the mass media represents ‘brown’ people in a negative light.

He illustrates how these kind of shows generate and enforce the stereotypes that ‘brown’ people surely have to live by. While these types of shows are made to entertain, this negative reinforcement only show the bad side of Polynesian and Maori people. One of the major themes of the film ‘Manurewa’ is around people being trapped by low anticipations and unseen boundaries. People can become captured from obtaining success, caught from satisfying their potential, and caught from being heard.

The message in the film ‘Manurewa’ is that only some ‘brown’ people will be bad, however the expectations that their stereotypes have created for them along with the individuals who they are encircled with typically leads to these people making horrific mistakes. In this true tale, a good person has been encircled with out of work, violent people and finally ends up carrying out a homicide. In the beginning in the film the boy implies that he does have love and passion in his heart through nourishing and growing the equine.

After the murder the three older men are happy and excited but the boy was completely troubled about what he had done. Those two scenes plainly show the fact that boy is a good person who just made a negative mistakes as a result of people that he was surrounded by. When Joshua Iosefo performed ‘Brown Brother’ on the Tedx convention, he described how brown people are trapped because of expectations, and surroundings. Meaning that the expectations which were set from your stereotypes and also the people that they may be surrounded by effect greatly and almost trap darkish people by success.

He used a box as one example, where he explained that each side of the box needs to be kicked down to ensure that Maori and Polynesian visitors to succeed. You need to make the change themselves through their own activities. ‘Brown’ we all need to stop being what the stereotypes expects these to be and need to commence proving that they are better than the stereotype. In the short account, ‘Fish Heads’ the Maori boys are lack of money however they do not let this stop all of them.

All four boys are employed, they each work for the tiny money they own and they demonstrate that there is not any reason to live the way the stereotype needs them to live. They are not really violent, they just do not commit crimes and they usually do not drink alcohol too much. They value people and they are generally happy living a simple healthy life.

Likewise, Joshua Iosefo talks about defeating the belief, about standing up and showing that you are much better than the belief. “You may do everything through Christ, Philippians four: 13. You are more than capable. And i also don’t declare just to allow you to feel better, I say that because I know. Trigger your inventor told me to share with you therefore.

You will get places, you will tell stories, so do certainly not feel frightened or by itself for your Goodness and your family plus your home can forever become inside the marrow of your bone fragments. So do not really fret, usually do not regret. To get where you get, you take us with you.

Brown brother, do not be frightened to be the first, the first to graduate student, the first to ascend, the initially prime minister,  or the first very good wife — brown sibling, do not be scared to be the transform. Not in skin tone or colour, nevertheless a change in mindset. From a single brown brother, to another”. These are the powerful phrases that Joshua pointed for people living under the objectives that the belief has established for them.

This kind of powerful concept is focused st those who have been beaten by the anticipations that have been established by the belief. The three text messaging, ‘Manurewa’, ‘Brown Brother’ and ‘Fish Heads’ clearly illustrate that there are bad stereotypes and low anticipations for Polynesians and Maori in Fresh Zealand. These kinds of stereotypes usually leads people to believe that they are caught and defined by their stereotype.

Joshua Iosefo’s speech, spoken of the belief that was his ‘demographic’ but also said that Polynesians needed to be accountable for overcoming or changing this stereotype. In the film ‘Manurewa’, the inability intended for Isaac to escape from this cycle of disbelief lead the once qualified teenager to associate with bad persons and eventually lead to him murdering a great innocent man. Whereas in comparison, the text ‘Fish Heads’ showed that if perhaps people are taken off negative surroundings and impacts, they are able to live in a non-stereotypical way.